Sun 7 Mar 2010
This post documents my current opinion about the front end of Google Mail, both its positive and negative aspects. I used it for two days after we switched from Microsoft Exchange to Google Apps. My head was spinning so much that I had to switch back to Outlook 2007.
My biggest gripes (If Google adds these features then I will reconsider and possibly switch back.):
- No highlighting of messages ONLY sent to me. I need this because in our collaborative environment most of my emails are sent to the whole team. I have to be able to quickly identify if a message is sent only to me so that I can respond accordingly.
- Categorization (aka Filtering) is still very basic compared to Outlook Rules.
- Only one signature
- No signature on Replies
- No Preview pane
- The biggest gripe by far: It took Google 8 (yes, that is eight!) days to respond to my first support request (Postini was withholding valid emails for 3 hours before they were delivered)!!!
Stuff I still have to get used to:
- Ads everywhere (this will probably never change and I have to remind myself that this is what makes Google Apps so affordable)
- Screen layout not really customizable (apart from adding a logo and changing the background). The benefit is that you are forced to keep it simple.
- Email conversations are grouped together, which can make it easy to follow a topic, but it is also clutters the screen layout.
Things I like:
- Runs in a browser (obviously) on any machine or platform. But then again, so does Outlook Web Access.
- Google Mail makes it easy to eliminate the use of folders, which I never liked and haven’t done for a long time anyway. Unfortunately Outlook makes it very easy to create and manage folders, but when you have hundreds of them it gets unwieldy. I normally recommend using Filters (in Google Mail) or Rules (in Outlook) to categorize items.
- Last but not least: The price. In fact, that is probably the most important aspect. If Exchange was not so darned expensive (unless you are a non-profit) I think Microsoft would not have so much to worry about.
Personally I do not get a big productivity boost from Google’s legendary Search algorithms either. Not that it is any worse than Outlook Instant Search, it is just that I expected more. I guess I am spoiled with Outlook 2007 Instant Search running on a Dell Latitude E4300 with a Core 2 Duo P9600 Processor and Windows 7 and Solid State Drives. My Instant Searches are super fast and the Indexing process does not consume a lot of resources, something older machines have a problem with (I generally recommend shutting off Windows Search if you have XP or an older, slower machine).



